Winning a new customer almost always costs more than bringing back one who has already bought from you. A loyalty program is a way to bring them back: the customer earns points, a discount or a gift and returns to you rather than to the shop next door. Below: what kinds of programs exist, where to run them, how to work out the return, what development costs and the most common mistakes.
When a loyalty program makes sense
A program works when customers buy from you regularly: a coffee shop, a restaurant, a store, a beauty salon, a car wash, a pharmacy, a delivery service. If people buy once every few years, as with a home renovation, points will change little.
The other condition is that you already have a flow of customers. A loyalty program retains, it does not attract. If customers are still few, the money is better spent on promotion. More on this in a website for a cafe or restaurant, where loyalty sits on the list of things that can wait.
Types of programs
- Points and cashback. Each purchase earns a percentage in points that can pay for part of later purchases. The most flexible option: you can change the rate, give double points on chosen days, gift points on birthdays.
- Tiered discount. The more a customer has spent, the higher their permanent discount. Easy to explain, but the discount cuts revenue on every purchase for good.
- Stamps. Every sixth coffee free. Everyone understands it, and it suits one or two popular products well.
- Levels. Silver, gold and platinum customers with different perks. Works when there is a clear gap between ordinary and the most active customers.
- Referrals. Points for bringing a friend. A good addition to any of the programs above.
For most small and medium businesses it makes sense to start with points or stamps: they are easy to launch and easy to measure.
Where to run the program
A card in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet
The customer scans a QR code at the till or follows a link, and the card appears on their phone next to their bank cards. Nothing to install; the points balance updates on the card, and the card can receive notifications. A quick and inexpensive start.
A Telegram bot
The customer finds the bot through a link or QR code, signs up with a phone number and sees their balance, history and offers. The bot can send reminders and personal offers. More on bots in Telegram bot for business.
A mobile app
The most capable option: in an app customers can not only collect points but also order, pay, book and see their purchase history. An app brings push notifications and personal offers based on what the customer buys. But it has to be installed, and development costs more. It is justified when you have many regular customers or need an app for other things too, for example delivery.
A common path: start with a Wallet card or a Telegram bot, see how customers use the program, and after six months to a year move it into an app together with ordering and payments.
How to work out the return
Before launch, answer three questions.
- How much are you willing to spend to bring a customer back. If the average check is $10 and the margin is 40%, 5% cashback costs you 12.5% of the profit on a purchase. Whether that is a lot depends on how much more often the customer starts coming.
- How often do customers return today. Without this figure you will not know later whether the program worked. If purchases are not tied to customers yet, start with at least tracking by phone number.
- What happens to unspent points. Points usually expire, for example after a year. That is normal practice, but the rules must be clear to customers from the start.
After launch, look not at the number of members but at whether members come more often and spend more than other customers.
Links to the till, CRM and 1C
A loyalty program lives next to sales, so it almost always needs to be connected to something:
- The till. Points are awarded and redeemed automatically at payment. Without this the cashier enters everything by hand, which leads to errors and abuse.
- The CRM. Managers see a customer’s balance and history, and marketing can message segments. More in CRM for small business.
- 1C. If sales and stock are kept in 1C, purchases and points are convenient to take from there. How that works: connecting to 1C.
At the start you can do without integrations: the cashier finds the customer by phone number in a simple web interface and awards points. Once customers are many, automation pays off quickly.
How much a loyalty program costs
The price depends on where the program runs and what it connects to.
- A Wallet card or a Telegram bot with points and a simple panel for the cashier and admin. Priced as a web service: at NOVO a prototype from $300, a first version from $1,200.
- A program inside a mobile app together with a catalog, ordering and notifications. A first app version from $1,500, a full app from $4,000.
- Integrations with the till, CRM or 1C are added to any option and estimated after we look at your systems.
More on app prices in how much a mobile app costs.
Common mistakes
- Rules that are too complex. If a customer has to read two pages of terms, they will not join. The rule should fit in one sentence.
- Points that cannot be spent. A high redemption threshold or redemption on only some products annoys more than having no program.
- No tracking before launch. Without “before” figures you cannot tell whether the program works.
- Spam. Daily messages quickly lead to unsubscribes. Write when you have something to offer.
- Customer data without consent. Consent to personal data processing and to marketing messages must be collected at sign-up.
In short
- A loyalty program brings back customers who buy regularly, but it does not replace winning new ones.
- Points or stamps are the best start: easy to explain and easy to measure.
- A Wallet card or a Telegram bot is the fastest launch; an app is justified with a large customer base.
- Work out the cost of points in advance and compare members’ behaviour with other customers.
- A link to the till and CRM removes manual entry and abuse. More on development on the web services and mobile apps pages.